[NA-Discuss] FW: [ALAC-Announce] Global ALAC election process/NARALO election process
Danny Younger
dannyyounger at yahoo.com
Thu Sep 4 09:17:14 EDT 2008
Sorry,
But I don't agree with the procedures.
Per the ALAC Internal Rules of Procedure ALAC members must meet minimum participation requirements. If they do not meet such requirements, they will be asked (per the rules that they themselves adopted) by the Chair to resign. If a resignation is not forthcoming within 14 days, the Chair will notify the RALO that a recall procedure is warranted.
The Participation Report has recently been posted by ICANN Staff and neither of the NARALO elected representatives met the minimum participation requirements. Accordingly, we can expect two (2) seats to be vacated, not just one.
I would ask the Secretariat to contact the ALAC chair to determine whether the required resignations have been tendered or whether we are advised to begin a recall procedure.
regards,
Danny
--- On Thu, 9/4/08, Thompson, Darlene <DThompson at GOV.NU.CA> wrote:
> From: Thompson, Darlene <DThompson at GOV.NU.CA>
> Subject: [NA-Discuss] FW: [ALAC-Announce] Global ALAC election process/NARALO election process
> To: "ALAC NA Discuss" <na-discuss at atlarge-lists.icann.org>
> Date: Thursday, September 4, 2008, 9:07 AM
> Hi all,
>
> I have just been reviewing our organizing documents and it
> appears that I have missed a deadline for the ALAC election.
>
> Our Operating Principles state that "At least once a
> year, on or before the First of July, or whenever a vacancy
> arises, the NARALO shall issue a call for Statements of
> Interest from members of the North American Internet
> community to serve on the ALAC. The call for Statements of
> Interest shall be open for at least 30 days. At least once a
> year, on or before the First of July, or whenever a vacancy
> arises, the NARALO shall issue a call for Statements of
> Interest from members of the North American Internet
> community to serve on the ALAC. The call for Statements of
> Interest shall be open for at least 30 days."
>
> Since that date has come and gone, I would like to propose
> that we open the call for nominations as of our next
> telephone conference (this coming Monday) and hold it open
> for two weeks (rather than 30 days). I think that two weeks
> is plenty of time. Once all nominations are in, then we can
> use the on-line voting tools provided by staff to vote
> (within one week of the close of the nominating period) to
> be held open for one (or two?) weeks.
>
> Just as a note: The position that we are looking at is the
> ALAC seat that Beau is holding. Our OP allows for him to be
> elected for another term (of two years).
>
> Please let me know if you do not agree with the procedures
> that I have outlined above and I will try to correct it. We
> need to have this election completed prior to the Cairo
> meeting.
>
> Thanks,
>
> D
>
> Darlene A. Thompson
> Community Access Program Administrator
> Nunavut Dept. of Education / N-CAP
> P.O. Box 1000, Station 910
> Iqaluit, NU X0A 0H0
> Phone: (867) 975-5631
> Fax: (867) 975-5610
> E-mail: dthompson at gov.nu.ca
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: alac-announce-bounces at atlarge-lists.icann.org
> [mailto:alac-announce-bounces at atlarge-lists.icann.org] On
> Behalf Of At-Large Staff
> Sent: Friday, August 22, 2008 11:26 AM
> To: alac-announce at atlarge-lists.icann.org
> Subject: [ALAC-Announce] Global ALAC election process
>
> Dear all,
>
> As you know, the ICANN annual meeting in Cairo will mark
> the end of the
> terms of:
>
> 1. One Member of the At-Large Advisory Committee from
> each Geographic
> Region;
>
> 2. The officers of the ALAC;
>
> 3. The Liaisons appointed by the ALAC
>
> To help ensure the elections for the open positions run
> smoothly, this email
> will provide you with an overview of the election process
> as it relates to
> the elections of Members of the At-Large Advisory
> Committee. You will find:
>
> * The general provisions governing the elections (ICANN
> By-laws and ALAC
> rules of procedures)
> * A suggestion for an election timetable for all regions
> * The regional provisions governing the elections (regional
> MoU and
> Operating Principles)
> * An overview of open ALAC positions
>
> General provisions governing the elections
>
> When the RALOs were formed in 2006 and 2007, the Memoranda
> of Understanding
> (MOU) and regional Operating Principles did not, with one
> exception, cover
> the voting process (nomination period, timing and other
> rules governing the
> elections) in any detail. Most regional instruments only
> say that the region
> is responsible for electing two out of the three regional
> ALAC positions,
> the third position being appointed by the NomCom. Given
> the lack of clear
> provisions on the election process in the regional
> instruments, one needs to
> turn to the ICANN by-laws, the Rules of Procedure of the
> RALOs (for those
> which have adopted RoPs), and to the extent RALOs who would
> otherwise not
> have specific rules for the conduct of elections, if they
> so desire the ALAC
> rules of procedure.
> The ICANN by-laws, which apply to all regions, do not cover
> the election
> process but make clear that the regional ALAC members will
> serve two-year
> terms starting at the conclusion of an annual ICANN
> meeting. The terms are
> staggered, meaning that one term will start in an
> odd-numbered year and one
> term will start in an even-numbered year:
>
> ICANN Bylaws: Article Xi, Section 2.4.c
>
> 1. The term of one member selected by each RALO shall
> begin at the
> conclusion of an ICANN annual meeting in an even-numbered
> year.
>
> 2. The term of the other member selected by each RALO
> shall begin at the
> conclusion of an ICANN annual meeting in an odd-numbered
> year.
>
> See: http://www.icann.org/en/general/bylaws.htm
> <http://www.icann.org/en/general/bylaws.htm>
>
>
> At-Large Advisory Committee Internal Rules of Procedure
>
> The ALAC rules of procedure, on the other hand, only
> contain rules that
> apply to the ALAC officer elections:
> 1. Call for election: no earlier than one month before the
> ICANN meeting and
> no later than three weeks before an ICANN meeting (rule 9)
> 2. Deadline for nominations: 14 days after election call
> (rule 9)
> 3. Acceptance period: Nomination must be accepted no later
> than 7 days after
> the nomination deadline and no later than 7 days before the
> start of an
> ICANN meeting (rule 9)
>
> See: https://st.icann.org/alac/index.cgi?rules_of_procedure
> <https://st.icann.org/alac/index.cgi?rules_of_procedure>
> (At-Large Advisory
> Committee Rules of Procedure)
>
> Suggested election procedure for ALAC representatives:
>
> Since the RALOs have few details about the procedure by
> which they elect
> their ALAC members, it is suggested that the election
> process for ALAC
> representatives use the procedure by which ALAC elects
> officers and
> liaisons:
> * Call for election: The regional Secretariat will make a
> call for election
> no later than seven weeks before the start of the annual
> ICANN meeting (14
> September 2008)
> * Nomination Period: nominations shall be accepted for two
> weeks after the
> Secretariat calls for nominations (28 September 2008)
> * Acceptance deadline: the nominees need to accept their
> nomination no later
> than seven days after the nomination period ends (05
> October 2008)
> * Election deadline: The election shall begin no later than
> one week after
> the end of the acceptance deadline (12 October 2008) and
> end not later than
> two weeks before the start of the annual ICANN meeting. (19
> October 2008).
> In other words, votes would actually be cast between 12 to
> 19 October 2008)
>
> Voting Mechanism
>
> We would suggest that the online voting system used
> previously in various
> regions at www.bigpulse.com <http://www.bigpulse.com>
> (and which is used for
> all ALAC votes including for ALS Applications). The staff
> would administer
> these votes through the system, in all cases allowing
> independent
> verification via a URL located on the BigPulse servers
> which would provide
> the results of votes held.
>
> There are two regions NARALO and LACRALO which have
> adopted detailed
> Rules of Procedure for meetings. These RALOs may wish to
> use the elections
> procedures as specified in those RoPs, since they do
> provide clauses which
> allow online meetings to vote on various issues.
>
>
> Regional provisions governing the elections
>
> Various RALOs are at present speaking about the upcoming
> elections. A
> separate email communication follows this message that is
> tailored for each
> RALO, in hopes that this is useful in facilitating this
> process.
>
> AFRALO:
>
> a) Length of the nomination period: "a
> reasonable period shall be
> provided" (MOU:2.)
> b) Election date: not specified
> c) Additional provisions: one- year term, one vote
> per ALS (MOU:2)
>
> See:
> https://st.icann.org/afralo/index.cgi?mou_and_organising_documents
> <https://st.icann.org/afralo/index.cgi?mou_and_organising_documents
>
> To make sure that there will be staggered terms in all
> regions, it was
> decided that one of the current African ALAC positions
> shall be for two
> years and one should be for one years (see below for an
> overview of all open
> ALAC positions). In accordance with the ICANN bylaws, the
> terms of African
> ALAC representatives shall be set to two years.
>
> APRALO:
>
> a) Length of the nomination period: not specified
> b) Election date: not specified
> c) Additional provisions: "one vote per ALS"
>
> See:
> https://st.icann.org/asiapac/index.cgi?ralo_organising_documents
> <https://st.icann.org/asiapac/index.cgi?ralo_organising_documents
>
> EURALO:
>
> a) Length of the nomination period: not specified
> b) Election date: not specified
> c) Additional provisions: The European Mou says that ³The
> voting rights
> shall be determined by the EURALO.² (EURALO MoU, 5.4.1).
> According to the
> EURALO Bylaws, the European representatives elect the
> regional ALAC members
> at their General Assembly ( EURALO Bylaws, 11.10). The
> following rules
> govern the decisions of the GA: ³... each Member has one
> vote.² (11.4)
> whereas ³ Members of The Association shall consist of
> ...... organisations
> domiciled in Europe ........ which qualify as an ALS.²
> (EURALO Bylaws 4.1.)
>
> Additionally, the selected representatives must be members
> of different
> ALSes, must have their principal residence in different
> countries of the
> region and their nationalities must be different. To the
> extent possible,
> gender balance and regional balance within Europe shall be
> fostered.²(11.5
> EURALO Bylaws).
>
> See:
> https://st.icann.org/euralo/index.cgi?ralo_organising_instruments
> <https://st.icann.org/euralo/index.cgi?ralo_organising_instruments>
>
> LACRALO:
>
> a) Length of the nomination period: not specified
> b) Election date: not specified
> c) Additional provisions: two-year terms, "no
> re-election", one vote per
> ALS (Operating Principles 8)
>
>
> Detailed provisions for elections and voting during
> meetings can be found
> under:
> https://st.icann.org/lacralo/index.cgi?ralo_organising_documents
> <https://st.icann.org/lacralo/index.cgi?ralo_organising_documents>
>
> It is up to the region to decide if it wishes to treat the
> election as if it
> were a meeting.
>
> NARALO:
>
> a) Length of the nomination period: 30 days (Operating
> Principles 11)
> Start of nomination period: on or before 1 July (OP 11)
> b) Election date: "sufficiently in advance of
> ICANN's annual meeting" (OP
> 11)
> c) Additional provisions: ALAC representatives may not
> serve more than two
> consecutive terms (OP 10)
>
>
> Detailed provisions for elections and voting during
> meetings can be found
> under:
> See:
> https://st.icann.org/naralo/index.cgi?ralo_organizing_documents
> <https://st.icann.org/naralo/index.cgi?ralo_organizing_documents>
>
> It is up to the region to decide if it wishes to treat the
> election as if it
> were a meeting.
>
>
> Open ALAC positions:
>
> AFRALO: Hawa Diakité¹s term expires after the annual
> ICANN meeting in 2008
> APRALO: Izumi Aizu¹s term expires after the annual ICANN
> meeting in 2008
> EURALO: Sébastien Bachollet¹s term expires after the
> annual ICANN meeting in
> 2008. Veronica Cretu stepped back from her position earlier
> this year. It is
> suggested that there shall be a call for somebody to
> replace her until the
> end of her term, which ends at the end of the ICANN annual
> meeting in 2009.
> LACRALO: José Ovidio Salgueiro¹s term expires after the
> annual ICANN meeting
> in 2008
> NARALO: Beau Brendler¹s term expires after the annual
> ICANN meeting in Cairo
>
>
> Minimum Participation Requirements
>
> With respect to the Minimum Participation Requirements for
> Members of the
> At-Large Advisory Committee, the ALAC Rules of Procedure in
> Rule 21 is
> relevant.
>
> Rule 21.9 is of particular importance as it talks about the
> quantitative
> requirements. They are:
>
> A) Participation in at least 2/3 of the ALAC conference
> calls in any 6-month
> period
> B) Attending at least one physical meeting in any 9 month
> period
> C) Completing at least one feedback survey on At-Large
> issues in any 6 month
> period
>
> With regards rules A) and B) above, please find attached
> the attendance
> record for ALAC members and Liaisons. It covers the nine
> months preceding
> August 2008. The Staff will keep this up to date and
> publicly accessible.
>
> Regards,
>
> Nick Ashton-Hart, Matthias Langenegger, Frederic Teboul
> ICANN At-Large Staff
> email: staff at atlarge.icann.org
>
>
> ------
> NA-Discuss mailing list
> NA-Discuss at atlarge-lists.icann.org
> http://atlarge-lists.icann.org/mailman/listinfo/na-discuss_atlarge-lists.icann.org
>
> Visit the NARALO online at http://www.naralo.org
> ------
More information about the NA-Discuss
mailing list